LeBas, N. R.; Tomkins, J. L.; Olsson, M. L.

The evolution of alternative male reproductive strategies represents an intriguing evolutionary phenomenon. Divergent strategies are persistently at risk of local extinction or invasion, depending on the suites of traits expressed within and between morphs; hence, understanding the correlational selection that aligns reproductive strategies with behaviour, morphology and physiology is key to understanding the origin and maintenance of genetic polymorphisms. In the polychromatic painted dragon, Ctenophorus pictus, yellow, orange and red morphs are well characterised, but the blue morph has been historically absent from studied populations. Here we document the local distribution, morphology and male-contest interactions in a population where blue males are relatively common. We find that blue males express head colouration after a reaching a threshold body size, and that small blue males can reside in close proximity to other males; patterns consistent with a novel size-dependent conditional tactic within the suite of genetic strategies seen in this species. Condition-dependent, positively allometric throat bibs were non-randomly distributed among male morphs, implicating variation in correlational selection and the genetic architecture of the polymorphism. We were unable to definitively assign a morph that was superior in male competition but found that within morphs, male size was the determinant of competitive success, whilst between morphs it was not. Furthermore, contests between morphs were resolved with less aggression than contests within morphs, supporting the idea that badges resolve conflict, and that the invasion of new colour morphs may be facilitated by negative frequency dependent benefits to novel colour variants. These findings highlight the divergent phenotypic, genetic and selective environments that lead to the diversity of colour morphs.